What happens if trustees disagree?
Last reviewed · Reviewed by [REVIEWER NAME, CREDENTIALS]
This guide covers the law in England and Wales only. Scotland and Northern Ireland have different rules.
If trustees of a private family trust disagree, the decision usually cannot be made, because their decisions must be unanimous unless the trust document says otherwise.
Why one trustee can block a decision
Trustees of a private trust act together. In general, they all have to agree before they use a power, such as paying money to a beneficiary. Charities and some pension schemes follow different rules.
Check the trust deed first. Some deeds let a majority decide, or give one person a casting vote.
If you cannot agree, nothing happens. The money stays where it is. That can be the safe result, but long deadlock can harm the beneficiaries.
Ways to break a deadlock
- Talk it through and write it down. Set out each view, the facts and what the trust document allows. Re-read the letter of wishes. Often the gap is smaller than it seems.
- Look for a middle way. A smaller payment, a staged payment, or paying a bill directly instead of giving cash.
- Get independent advice. A solicitor’s view on what the deed allows, or an adviser’s view on the money, can settle the question. The cost can normally come from the trust.
- Try mediation. A neutral mediator helps you reach an agreement. It is usually cheaper and quicker than court.
- Step down. A trustee who cannot work with the others can retire, either with a replacement or, if at least two trustees will remain and consents are given by deed, without one.
- Apply to court. As a last resort, the trustees or a beneficiary can ask the court for directions. In a serious case, the court can also replace a trustee. This is slow and expensive, and costs may come from the trust.
When a trustee will not take part at all
Disagreeing is different from refusing to act. If a trustee stops replying or refuses to do anything, section 36 of the Trustee Act 1925 lets a replacement be appointed in place of a trustee who refuses or is unfit to act. Keep a record of your attempts to contact them, and take advice first.
Keep a record
Whatever happens, note each meeting, what was proposed and who agreed. If the decision is ever questioned, a clear record shows you acted carefully. You can book a free chat if you would like to talk your options through.
Read our guide to making decisions as a trustee.