Making decisions as a trustee
Good trustee decisions follow the trust document, consider the letter of wishes and every beneficiary, involve all the trustees, and are written down with the reasons.
Last reviewed · Reviewed by [REVIEWER NAME, CREDENTIALS]
This guide covers the law in England and Wales only. Scotland and Northern Ireland have different rules.
Trustees make decisions that matter to people’s lives. This guide explains how to make them well. It covers England and Wales.
Start with the trust document
Every decision starts with the trust deed, or the Will. It tells you who can benefit and what you are allowed to do. If the document does not allow something, you cannot do it.
Using your discretion
In a discretionary trust, you choose who benefits, how much and when. No beneficiary has a right to the money until you decide.
That freedom comes with a duty to think it through. For each decision:
- Consider every beneficiary, not only the one asking.
- Think about what each person needs now and may need later.
- Ask whether a payment is best made as cash, or by paying a bill directly.
- Check the trust has enough left for the future.
The letter of wishes
The letter of wishes tells you what the settlor would like. Read it before every important decision. It is a guide, not an instruction. You must still use your own judgement for the beneficiaries.
If circumstances have changed a lot since the letter was written, it is right to take that into account. Read our guide to letters of wishes.
Some decisions you cannot hand over
The Trustee Act 2000 lets trustees employ agents, such as an investment manager. But some decisions cannot be delegated. They include:
- whether, or how, trust assets are distributed to beneficiaries
- whether fees or other payments come out of income or capital
- appointing a new trustee
You can take advice on all of these. The decision itself stays with the trustees.
Working with your fellow trustees
Make decisions together. Share the papers, talk it through and record who agreed.
If you cannot agree, take time. Ask what the letter of wishes suggests, and consider getting independent advice. TODO-VERIFY: whether trustees of a private trust must decide unanimously unless the trust document says otherwise, and what happens if they cannot agree.
When you are also a beneficiary
Family trusts often name a beneficiary as a trustee. That is allowed, but it creates a risk of a conflict of interest.
- Tell your fellow trustees when a decision affects you.
- Be fair to the other beneficiaries.
- Write down your reasons with extra care.
- If a decision mainly benefits you, consider taking advice first.
TODO-VERIFY: the legal rules on a trustee-beneficiary taking part in decisions that benefit them.
When beneficiaries ask for money
Take each request seriously. Ask what the money is for, and whether there is a better way to help. Then decide together and write it down.
Saying no is sometimes the right answer. Explain it kindly and, where you can, offer another kind of help. For example, paying a course fee directly instead of giving cash.
Real situations
What if a beneficiary with an addiction asks for cash
The situation
Liam is in recovery from a drug addiction. He asks the trustees for £20,000 in cash to 'get back on his feet'. A lump sum could put his recovery at risk.
A good way to handle it
Talk to Liam about what he needs. Pay his rent, a training course or treatment directly to the provider. Agree to review it again in six months, and write down your reasons.
What if two trustees disagree
The situation
Helen wants to give her nephew £30,000 towards a house. Her co-trustee Martin thinks it is too much and unfair to the other grandchildren.
A good way to handle it
Look at the letter of wishes together. Consider a smaller payment, or a loan from the trust if the document allows it. If you still cannot agree, get independent advice before anything is paid.
What if a beneficiary's new partner puts pressure on you
The situation
After her husband died, Jean is a beneficiary of his Will trust. Her new partner keeps calling the trustees, asking for money for a joint business.
A good way to handle it
Deal only with Jean, in writing. Consider her own needs and interests, not her partner's. Ask for a business plan if a payment is even possible, and take advice if anyone is being pressured.
What if a grandchild wants a house deposit
The situation
Chloe, 26, asks for £25,000 towards her first home. The letter of wishes says the grandchildren should be helped onto the property ladder.
A good way to handle it
Check the trust has enough left for the other grandchildren. Pay the money to the conveyancing solicitor, not to Chloe's own account. Record the decision and the reasons.
A written decision
Keep a note like this for every significant decision. Our guide to documents to keep explains why.
When to get advice
Get help from a solicitor or other adviser if:
- you are not sure the trust document allows something
- a decision involves a large part of the trust
- a trustee has a conflict of interest
- a beneficiary is vulnerable or under pressure
- the trustees cannot agree
For investment decisions, see our guide to investing trust money. For the tax side, see tax and deadlines.
Frequently asked questions
Do we have to follow the letter of wishes?
No. It guides you but does not bind you. You should read it and take it seriously, then make your own decision for the beneficiaries.
Can we ask a solicitor or adviser to decide who gets the money?
No. The Trustee Act 2000 does not let trustees hand over decisions about whether or how trust assets are distributed. You can get advice, but the decision stays with you.
Do we have to give a beneficiary money if they ask?
In a discretionary trust, no beneficiary has a right to the money. You must consider the request properly, but you can say no.
What if one of us is also a beneficiary?
That is common, but take extra care. Be open about it, consider the other beneficiaries fairly and write down your reasons. If in doubt, take advice.